Buckeye Cookies are a no bake cookie without eggs that is a perfect combination of peanut butter and chocolate. They are creamy, delicious and never last long in our house so I always make a double batch.
I am reminded every year to make these Buckeye Cookies for Christmas. My granddaughter asks for them all year long and I try to explain to her that if I make them all the time she won’t look forward to them at Christmas. She looks at me like I’m nuts.
Click on the link below for step by step instructions with pictures and a printable recipe card.
People who bake these year-round run the risk of increasing their weight by 20 lbs.. :-]
Erm, “make” not “bake”.
Sounds like a good snack to me!
These No Bake cookies are really interesting…👍 Looks too delicious 👍
My favorite!! Going to have to try your version 🙂
Your chocolate/peanut butter combinations are driving me a little insane…in a good way!
I’m a big fan of these buck eyes!
Me too! I hate making them because they are time consuming but boy do I like to eat them!
Oh wow I’ve never seen these before. They look absolutely amazing. They wouldn’t last long in my house either! 🤣🤣
Lol it’s that peanut butter and chocolate combination!
A marriage made in heaven 😋
So good. I never knew how to make them so thank you for teaching me!
You’re very welcome!
I love these too Diane – my mom used to make them every Christmas as well.
They have been around forever! I have been making them for 40 years!
Me too! I save you some…lol
I so love these
They are the best aren’t they! Thanks!
I have never heard of these before! They look realllly nice though!
They are I think it is the peanut butter chocolate combination!
Looks amazing! Will try!
Oh I know I will!
Thank you! Have a great day!
Reblogged this on frangipani flower wearing tropical lady drinking jasmine green tea and commented:
nice idea for christmas time
woweee.I like this idea.great pictures.
These were a classic growing up in our home 🙂 Have to when you are from the buckeye state! I haven’t had one in forever though- and this recipe is making me crave um’. Thanks for sharing, Diane ! I have never tried making them myself, but I’ll have to!
They are time consuming but fun to make!
Omg, these are amazing!