Frozen Peanut Butter Pie
This Frozen Peanut Butter Pie is like eating ice cream! If you like peanut butter and chocolate you have to try this Frozen Peanut Butter Pie. I topped it off with Homemade Hot Fudge, here is the link to the Hot Fudge recipe.
This is one of the easiest pie’s you will ever make. I think my favorite thing about this pie is that you can make it at least a day ahead of time because it goes into the freezer and you serve it frozen!
This recipe was given to my husband by a co-worker many years ago. I do not know where this originated from but it sure is good!
Place all of the ingredients, except the
chocolate pie crust, into a medium bowl.
I find mixing the cream cheese and peanut
butter first, until creamy and no lumps, then
the rest of the ingredients turns out the best.
Using a mixer, beat until smooth
and thoroughly mixed.
Place the mixture into the chocolate
pie crust. Cover and place into the
freezer until completely frozen.
I made my pie a day ahead of time.
Slice frozen and drizzle with
hot fudge or chocolate syrup
and top with peanuts, optional.
Frozen Peanut Butter Pie
- 1 – 6 oz prepared chocolate pie crust (or make your own)
- 1 cup powdered sugar
- 1/2 cup milk
- 3 oz cream cheese (softened and cream with the back of a spoon before adding)
- 8 oz Cool Whip (or your favorite whipped topping)
- 3/4 cup creamy peanut butter
- In a medium bowl, using a mixer on low speed, combine the peanut butter and cream cheese until smooth and with no lumps.
- Add all of the ingredients except the pie crust.
- Use a mixer and beat until smooth and thoroughly mixed.
- Place the mixture into the pie crust, cover and freeze overnight.
- Serve frozen with Hot Fudge or chocolate syrup and top with peanuts, optional.
So yummmm 😍😍😍
Thanks you Sunaina
All I can say is Yum! One of my very favorite pies 😉
Thanks I like this one because it is frozen!
This sounds fantastic!
this looks fairly easy & sounds absolutely delicious! thanks for sharing 🙂
It was amazing! Thanks
oh, wow. A dessert that will definitely be made by me. Thank you.
It’s awesome! You’re welcome!
Not certain I should even let my wife see this recipe. Peanut butter is one of her essential food groups.
Hahaha surprise her and make it for her😉
Yum!!! This looks absolutely delicious!! 😍😍😍
Thank you it was a huge hit!
That looks irresistible😊
Oh, can’t wait to try this!
It is worth the wait! Thank you Rosemarie!
Wow, this looks and sounds so yum! 🙂
It was fabulous thanks!
I must make this for your Dad for Fathers Day. Don’t tell him. Yum.
Make the hot fudge too!
This sounds amazing. I’m not a huge chocolate fan but I eat it every now and then so long as it’s not a rich chocolate.
WOW!!! Making this pie asap, looks incredible and I’m sure my family would love it 😀
Definitely make the hot fudge to go with it! Let me know what you think.
OMG! This looks and sounds sooooo good. I love peanut butter and chocolate. Can’t wait to try it out!
It was very good. Try the homemade hot fudge on top too! Thanks so much!
This looks so delicious! I’m thinking I’ll whip one up for Memorial Day 🙂
Great holiday dessert. What’s nice is you can make it a few days before since it’s frozen. Thank you!
My fav! peanut butter ice cream is my weak spot… this looks sooo delicious!
We have a local ice cream parlor that sells a chocolate ice cream with peanut butter chunks all through it! SO GOOD! Thanks Marylin!
The name would be enough to make me salivate😋
You are so right! Thanks Ortensia
This really has my mouth watering. It sounds absolutely delicious.
Believe me, it is!!!! The homemade Hot Fudge sets it over the top! Great combination.
Hahahaha thank you very much!
Looks delicious – I love anything peanut butter.
Me too! Thank you Linda!
That looks absolutely scrumptious, Diane!
Thank you Karin!
Looks so gorgeous & delicious ! I love it !!
It made for a great Mother’s Day dessert! Thank you!
All i can say is yum. My son would love this.
I’m with your son! Lol
Is it possible that I gained two pounds simply by looking at your recipe? 😊
Hahahaha it is quite possible!
Peanut butter and chocolate, yum! My favorite!
It was SO GOOD! I love that it is frozen so I can enjoy it longer without it going bad. Thank you!
I am definitely going to try it!
It is amazing!
Oh, yeah! Yummy!
so yum! perfect for guests at dinner
Thank you I will have plenty to feed today!
This looks soooo good! It’s getting late here but I’m going to be dreaming of this all night. I’m definitely trying this!
Sweet dreams! 😂🤣😂🤣
Wow! This recipe is a keeper along with the hot fudge recipe (and the Hershey one too!)
Everything about all three recipes is amazing but I love hot fudge on this the best. Thank you❤️
Anytime someone mentions a frozen pie I am all in. This looks delicious. Peanuts on top? Yes, please!
Hot fudge too! Lol Thank you ❤️